Sunday, March 15, 2009

Review: Reaching Past the Wire

Here's some fairly old news I wrote, to remind us all to wake up to our surroundings.


The Human Face on War

How will Minnesotans acknowledge Iraq war veterans? At every gathering that recognizes those coming back from the war, there is likely to be a mix of people that are grateful, concerned, and critical.

One grandmother retired from the Army Reserves, and came home to Minnesota and a grateful church and group of friends, a concerned family, and a public very critical of her work at Abu Ghraib prison. Readers from human rights groups like Tackling Torture at the Top and sympathetic peers with military experience alike heard what Deanna Germain had to say at her book reading.

On Wednesday, Sept. 5, 2007, Army nurse and author Deanna Germain publicly read from her memoir, Reaching Past the Wire: A Nurse at Abu Ghraib, at McKawber's bookstore. The reading was hosted by St. Paul Public Libraries.

Deanna Germain served as an army nurse reservist in Abu Ghraib and Kuwait. Connie Lounsbury had approached Deanna about writing the book on her military service in the prison hospital, after she heard about it from Germain's sisters. Germain agreed to expand on the emails to her sisters that she'd written, hoping, as she said at her book reading, to “put a human face on war.” The proceeds of her memoir's sales go to the Fisher House Foundation. The national private-public foundation builds and keeps 'comfort homes' on the grounds of major military and VA medical centers, for family members to be close to a loved one in the military during hospitalization for an unexpected illness, disease, or injury.

She worked not in “the hard district” of the prison, but in a hospital, separated by an arm's length of razor-wire from about 4,000 detainees. Her patients came in from Fallujah and Ramadi and nearby villages. They were often injured in combat against US forces, according to Germain. Some prisoners didn't want to describe their injuries, perhaps because their past activities could have endangered their families if they had confessed them.

“I knew some detainees were in the wrong place at the wrong time,” Germain said. She described the example of Sami, 15 years old, who was on a bus as “insurgents” blew it up-- and became one of her patients. “We tried to sort people, but it couldn't be done fast enough-- frustrating on all sides-- so a lot more ended up behind the wire,” she said, implying that there were a lot more there who shouldn't have been.

Reaching Past The Wire mostly details her relationships with coworkers, translators, and what she learned from the Iraqi prisoners and civilians she treated. The only section she read aloud at McKawber's was about her daily discomforts and weekly inconveniences: wearing armor all the time, seeing rats crawl over her feet as she tried to make a phone call, and having a cell of the prison for a bedroom. “War is hell,” she read.

Before publishing their book, Germain and Lounsbury sent it to the Judge Advocate General, in case they wanted to look it over. The office gave no response.

The small, crowded bookstore was full of questioning listeners. Germain grimaced as audience members bluntly brought the question of the Abu Ghraib prisoner maltreatment scandals up, just as they had been brought up to her so many times before.

She said that she knew no one at “the hard site,” and could find out nothing about it. Germain said, “I found out about the instance of abuse from my sister who emailed me, who said, 'WHAT IS HAPPENING OVER THERE?'

“We were watching BBC and any channel we could get, to find some information.

When we did have the reporters people coming through, it was obvious to the patients. We could not tell any of the prisoners or detainees what was happening, but it was pretty obvious that life had pretty quickly changed in our hospital.”

After piecing together snippets of information from whatever television and Internet time thy could afford, Germain and her coworkers reacted to the prisoner abuse with uncertainty and anger. “I haven't known soldiers who would do things like that!” Germain told the audience. “We did a lot of self-evaluation: What are we doing here? If we can change one heart or mind, that'll be our goal.”

Germain wrote one short chapter about prisoner abuse at Abu Ghraib, in the middle of her memoir: “When I came to Abu Ghraib, I realized that the soldiers here seemed of a different breed, a little independent of the whole, because we had to be, for survival...We just hoped the leaders would keep things in control....If I asked about anything outside the hospital or had questions about who else was in the camp and what they did, I got vague answers.”

She wrote of the possibility that the hospital distracted the International Red Cross, and other organizations that visited and checked on it, from torture interrogations not too far away: “I have wondered if the hospital where I served was set up as a response, a way to counterbalance it by providing better care for detainees.” This profound line of reason on page 79 was not revisited anywhere else in the book.

When asked about the conditions that prompted and allowed prisoner abuse, Germain said, “When strong...leadership presence isn't there, that can happen.” She added that a lot of medics were 19 or 20 years old, on their first job, “and a lot of young people need supervision-- people to guide them. And they didn't have that.”

Germain enlisted when she was young, in 1970. She provided care for soldiers in Vietnam, and then in America, in the Individual Ready Reserve during Desert Storm. “Thirty days before my retirement, I was called into active duty,” she said. She was called to Abu Ghraib, outside of Fallujah, Iraq, to serve 540 more days in the army than she meant to.

Germain expressed little regret, however. “I think I'm much more aware of what service and sacrifice [are], than before I went on this mission... The next chapter: we're a very rich country; we need to share more with those who have less.”

After giving many copies of her book personal autographs, Germain expanded on this idea of a new chapter for the soldiers, whom she looks on not as fighters, but as protectors. She “joined to protect and serve.” When asked what the military protects, she said, “What we have.” When asked what “we have,” she took a moment.

“Democracy, safety-- I guess that's subjective now. I can't... sorry, it's not a complete thought.”


Germain didn't understand what was going on at Abu Ghraib until outside sources caught the scent of scandal and told her, just as we often don't understand what's going on in the next block down from us, until an outside perspective is brought to our attention. Like Germain, we can wake up to our surroundings-- but are not likely to understand the deeper themes that cause our present dilemmas, which are outside and above and obscured from the news of what's going on.

Thursday, January 1, 2009

One small influence

The other day, Minnesotans gathered outside Senator Amy Klobuchar's office demanding to meet with her, and influence her regarding the Gaza strip crisis. After they occupied a conference room at the State Capitol, Senator Klobuchar agreed to meet with them.

I will write, though it is a small influence to make on someone else who has a small influence in this matter. But we all can do this, we all can add our influence.

Dear Senator Klobuchar,
Happy new year!
I write so that you can add another humanitarian to the demographic of your constituency.
Please also note that you can help change the US' arms deals with Israel in the Senate. This is very important as we in the US hear of more and more horrors that Israel commits against starving Palestinians in the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, with jets and weapons imported from the US.

This week, a humanitarian relief ship called the Dignity was trying to bring international advocates and food to the Gaza Strip, when it was surrounded by the Israeli navy, rammed and damaged. Fortunately a journalist from CNN was on board.That's how I found out about it, and I hope you too will learn more, & meet with the Minnesotans outside your door who come to tell of horrible things happening in the Middle East. We CAN end our complicity in them!

Thank you.

Tuesday, December 30, 2008

People without a Country, an Opportunity, or Food

Can you believe travesties of sickening proportions are happening now, are happening just as the patterns of history provide for, are happening just as prophesied and expected and yet they are not at all inevitable? Now, in our time, in our life, when we can do something about it and change it, or lose another part of our life stories to observation and complicity.

The Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank are people without a country, without enough land, without internationally recognized leadership or legal power.
They have few opportunities to make money, travel, to even get out of their fenced-in territories and into the country of Israel.
At least in the Gaza Strip, they can access the sea.
But today I woke to several real occurring, recurring nightmares of the Palestinians, happening in that world across the ocean and a sea from me, accessible only by pictures and letters and reports.

Now the people living in the Gaza Strip are running out of food, besides having been cut off from trade and all means of production.

Walled in, Bombed, Surrounded. I hardly imagined that things could get worse-- especially during and right after the holidays.

I hardly imagined that an American I care about would be in the center of this conflict's shifting storm, waking me up and making me care. (God, why do songs and celebrities pull me into the world's heartaches more than written pleas, documentaries, sermons or petitions?)

Ships and caravans and planes have headed to Gaza for many months with humanitarian relief. And today, the Dignity, a ship bearing humanitarians and journalists from many countries, was stopped on its relief mission to Gaza. Now I hear from the Anarchist Black Cross Federation, the US Campaign to End the Occupation of Palestine, and a US Social Forum group that the Dignity was surrounded by Israeli warships at 5 am (US Time) today and rammed into, damaged and losing fuel. The Dignity carries journalists from Al Jazeera, CNN, doctors, and one humanitarian from the US, Cynthia McKinney, who had recently run for President as a Green. Israel wants no dignity or food to arrive at the Gaza Strip for the starving, poor, and displaced, but rather wants the Dignity to return to its launching point, Cyprus, though it doesn't have enough fuel to do so.

How did I get word of this so soon? I don't even know how word got around, but besides prayer, it is our main starting point. The main way that these battles can engage the world.
http://www.cnn.com/2008/WORLD/meast/12/30/gaza.aid.boat/index.html

Tuesday, November 18, 2008

Lakotah need Emergency Aid

As of today, the Republic of Lakotah is in the twelfth day of a Snow Emergency.

The Chief Facilitator, Russel Means, is trying to alert the world, seeking better aid than the Red Cross provided.
  • Many hundreds of American Indians still snowbound and without electrical power or water on Pine Ridge Indian Reservation.
  • Sofia Romero, age 98, snowed in, no power, no water, food situation unknown.
  • Emme Zimiga, age 96, snowed in, no power, no water, food situation unknown.
  • Amanda Milk, age 80's, no legs, dialysis patient, snowed in, presumed dead.
  • Hisle SD - 38 households (average of 17 persons per household on Reservation) still snowed in with out power or water.
  • Lost Dog Community - 5 families snowed in, no power, no water, food situation unknown.
  • Lacreek Electric Association reports that over 1,000 power distribution poles broken by the storm have been replaced, but dozens more are still down, while repair efforts have been diverted to the some of the main distribution lines still partially inoperative.
  • Red Cross Effort Vehemently Incompetent - As documented by Marion White Mouse (605-462-6242), the American Red Cross sent a contingency of one volunteer, Monica Turkleson who departed the Reservation prematurely on Saturday, November 15th. Ms. Turkleson's "aide" consisted of nothing and her behavior was reported as impatient, rude and racist. Russell Means suggests that this organization change its name to the "White Cross."



Sunday, November 2, 2008

Private Army Designated by Bush

"Private Army Designated by Bush"

Published in the Augsburg College Echo, 10/31/08.

"NORTHCOMM and Urban Warfare"

Published in Women Against Military Madness newsletter, December '08

(http://www.worldwidewamm.org/newsletters/2008/12080109/northcomm.html)

If you’ve heard rumors about martial law in America, you may wonder how it would ever be possible, and what the supra-military force, NORTHCOMM, has to do with it.

Northern Command is a special military and intelligence joint task force that helps local, state, and tribal authorities in times of crisis on the North American continent. When the I-35 W bridge collapsed in Minneapolis on August 1, 2007, the US Navy was there to help, under a Region Defense Coordinating Officer of the US Northern Command. According to Northern Command’s timeline on its website, www.northcom.mil, the US division of NorthComm also helped states to mitigate flood damage in the Midwest last June. Here is why its new troops may be coming to a city near you in the near future, regardless of natural or manmade disasters in your area.

Deployment of NORTHCOMM


When a leader secures an army and security force dedicated to him and not to any Constitution, he lifts his own office above its prescribed role in the Constitution. That is what happened to the office of the President on October 1, as it has happened several times since George W. Bush took office.

On that day, the homeland tours of a 3,000-4,000 person army, the 1st Brigade Combat Team, began. NORTHCOMM leads this Brigade of the 3rd Infantry Division and it answers only to the President and the Secretary of Defense, not Congress, because the President established it on Oct. 1st 2002.

Congress has been funding it through bills like the Defense Authorization Act of 2007, but because of the secrecy of NORTHCOMM, Congress has even less oversight of it than it does over the five military branches.

The troops currently touring under NorthComm are the first to have ever been given a dedicated assignment to it. The 1st BCT had just returned from fighting in Iraq, and will tour America for 12 months, after which a different division will be assigned to this permanent mission, according to the Army Times. The Army Times’ article of September 30, “Brigade homeland tours start Oct. 1,” says that the 1st BCT will

      “learn new skills, use some of the ones they acquired in the war zone and more than likely will not be shot at while doing any of it. They may be called upon to help with civil unrest and crowd control or to deal with potentially horrific scenarios such as massive poisoning and chaos in response to a chemical, biological, radiological, nuclear or high-yield explosive, or CBRNE, attack.”

A CBRNE attack is any chemical, biological, radiological, nuclear, or high-yield explosive situations.

The article by Gina Cavallero can yet be found at http://www.armytimes.com/news/2008/09/army_homeland_090708w/

Urban Warfare

Controlling unrest could mean anything from fencing and guarding private property to demanding citizens' guns, house by house, as the National Guard and NorthComm did in New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina's devastation. ARMYNORTH, under NORTHCOMM, is not the first military division to have been trained in urban warfare in the U.S. However, the 1st BCT is also trained to use a special package of non-lethal weapons that will be stored at their tour sites: America’s cities. The above article was corrected so that readers understand the new non-lethal weapons packages can only be used in a war zone. But President Bush and his lawyers made the whole world a war zone with his unofficial declaration of the war on terror.

Appeasement


It didn’t take long for the active BCT to be used as a threat against the American people, as Representative Brad Sherman confessed on the House floor on October 2. During debate on H.R. 1424, the Emergency Economic Stabilization Act, he explained before his colleagues and C-SPAN that

      “Many of us were told in private conversations that if we voted against this bill, on Monday, that the sky would fall, the market would drop two or three thousand points the first day, another couple thousand the second day, and a few Members were even told that there would be martial law in America if we voted ‘no.’”

On October 3 the bill, nicknamed the corporate bail-out bill, was passed 263 to 171.

Emergencies


What does that threat of force have to do with the BCT’s mission to help in “potentially horrific scenarios?” Look at National Security Directive 51, which applies to natural and manmade emergencies. President Bush established his claim on emergency rule with National Security Directive 51 in May 2007. At this time America is not in a state of emergency. However, NSD 51 gives the President the power to determine what and where American emergencies are.

With only his own authority, he signed the executive directive so that, in a catastrophic emergency, “The President shall lead the activities of the Federal Government for ensuring constitutional government.” It’s hard to determine what that means when only Annex A of that Directive is available at the President’s website, http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2007/05/20070509-12.html

Peter Dale Scott looked into this in his article “The Showdown" on CounterPunch, March 31, 2008. He wrote, concerning members of the House Homeland Security Committee’s request to read the directive,

      NSPD 51 contains "classified Continuity Annexes" which shall "be protected from unauthorized disclosure." Congressman DeFazio twice requested to see these Annexes, the second time in a letter cosigned by House Homeland Security Committee Chairman Bennie Thompson and Oversight Subcommittee Chairman Christopher Carney. It was these requests that the White House denied.

------------------

For more, please research:

The US government’s Continuity of Operations plan, from 1946 to the present, and Donald Rumsfeld’s changes to it.

http://www.wikileaks.org/leak/us-army-reg-500-3-continuity-2001.pdf

The 2007 House Report 110-477, NATIONAL DEFENSE AUTHORIZATION ACT FOR FISCAL YEAR 2008, Section 1821.